Nikki M. James On Making ‘Little Store Of Horrors’ Historical past

When the curtains rise on the present Off-Broadway revival of Little Store of Horrors, audiences are handled to a cultural milestone hiding in plain sight. For the primary time, the central romantic duo of Audrey and Seymour is led by two Black actors: Tony Award-winner Nikki M. James and Jordan Fisher. It’s a placing evolution for a musical that has spent greater than forty years cemented in a selected, mid-century white aesthetic. But, getting into the enduring blonde, high-heeled footwear of Audrey felt like a pure homecoming for James, who just lately spoke to MadameNoire. 

“Audrey is a job that, though I stepped into it with such ease—I imply, I really feel like I placed on that black gown and people excessive heel footwear, and I knew precisely who she was—but, it was by no means a job that was on my bingo card as a result of I’d all the time seen non-people of colour play this half,” James displays. “And when it occurred—after I received the supply, I believed, ‘Oh my god, sure, that’s excellent.’ I like that in my 25 years on this enterprise, each the enterprise has modified sufficient that individuals are beginning to exit of the packing containers that they assume reveals or roles or characters are supposed to be performed by sure folks. And I additionally love that I’m nonetheless being stunned, that I’ve created a physique of labor that different folks see me as issues that I haven’t even seen in myself but. There’s one thing actually superb when an individual says, ‘You’d be nice at this,’ and also you suppose, ‘Actually?’ after which you’re. That implies that I’ve created a physique of labor and in addition relationships with administrators and musical administrators the place folks respect me, they usually’re fascinated by me in ways in which I’m not even fascinated by for myself. I’ve put my very own self in a field and different individuals are serving to me bust out.”

RELATED CONTENT: ‘Two Strangers’ Star Christiani Pitts Confronts The Concern Of Being Totally Seen As A Black Girl On Broadway — ‘It’s So Scary’ [Exclusive]

Bringing Untouched Humanity to an American Traditional

For many years, Audrey has typically been rendered as a tragic comedy, high-pitched archetype of a girl trapped by her circumstances on Skid Row. James approaches her not as a classic trope, however as a contemporary archetype of resilience.

“That is such a fantastic play, proper? It’s a fantastic musical, it’s a great story, it’s very humorous, and , it’s stunning, and it’s a bit scary. But it surely’s simply the concept that that is only a girl who has had a string of unhealthy luck, and he or she nonetheless has just a bit little bit of hope in her. Simply sufficient hope to placed on a great face and a few crimson lipstick, and go about her life. There’s one thing actually accessible about that, and I feel actually trendy, regardless that the present is 40 years previous and takes place in most likely the ’50s or the ’60s. There’s one thing actually timeless about an individual whose life circumstances haven’t fully overwhelmed her down—she nonetheless has a smile on her face. I cherished desirous to carry that humanity.”

Rejecting Laughs for Home Abuse

Maybe essentially the most profound selection James made in taking up the function was her refusal to deal with Audrey’s turbulent home actuality as humor. Traditionally, Audrey’s relationship with Orin Scrivello has been performed with a comedic edge. James firmly drew a boundary, selecting as a substitute to lean into the sobering weight of intimate companion violence.

“It’s not the funniest a part of the story to inform, however I actually didn’t need my efficiency for any of these moments that she is in, the place she is receiving bodily abuse from her companion, her boyfriend, to be performed for amusing. So, I’m not saying different folks haven’t carried out that, however that was a really critical and vital storyline for me and a plot level. She is de facto afraid of Orin. She begins the present with a black eye, and at one level she has a damaged arm—or she has a minimum of her arm in a forged, some type of sprained forged—and these are all accidents she’s sustained from her boyfriend. I actually strive to not play that for laughs.”

The inventive danger was instantly vindicated by the viewers’s real-world response. James recounts an emotional encounter on the stage door that solidified the need of her inventive decisions: “I felt actually rewarded in that. I used to be signing autographs on the autograph line, and a younger girl—I used to be signing her Playbill—and he or she mentioned, ‘This present modified my life.’ Not this manufacturing, however this present, Little Store, modified my life. I mentioned, ‘Oh, that’s candy.’ And she or he mentioned, ‘No, I do know many individuals say that, however I used to be in an abusive relationship, and I discovered this present, and it was really via this present that I used to be capable of see that I used to be in a relationship that was abusive, and I received out of it due to this present.’ That’s after I realized that I’m doing that a part of this present, of that Audrey, for girls like that.”

Audrey and Seymour

On the emotional core of the manufacturing is the enduring attraction of Audrey and Seymour’s dynamic, which continues to attraction theatregoers technology after technology. James attributes this to the character of mutual, unexpressed longing.

“I like that it’s this unrequited love that’s going each instructions. He’s in love along with her, and he thinks that she’s unattainable. And you then study in Someplace That’s Inexperienced that she type of has a sense for him, too, however in her thoughts, he’s too good for her. So, it’s these two people who find themselves pining for one another once they’re every afraid to say it till, , this plant comes into their life, and their life will get turned the other way up. After which he feeds my boyfriend to a plant, in order that opens the door for him, I assume! Not all of us are going to have man-eating crops in our lives to shake them awake, however I feel that’s one thing that’s actually candy about Audrey and Seymour. Once they lastly get collectively, it’s like Ross and Rachel getting collectively, or whoever. There’s one thing about two folks that are supposed to be collectively however can’t see it. Plus, , we sing nice collectively, in order that’s useful, too.”

The sheer magic of the manufacturing helps elevate that central bond. James expresses awe for the complicated puppetry that breathes life into Audrey II, the plant. “We joke that it’s an ideal musical,” she says. “It’s identical to the correct quantity of nice singing, a great sensible plot, stunning twists, humorous and heartbreaking, all in an escapist story that may solely exist on a magical stage. The puppetry is so unbelievable to observe. The artists who’re working the plant, they’re actually like magicians. They create this inanimate object to full life. I’m doing scenes with this plant, and I do know it’s two folks working it, however I’ve moments the place I’ve emotions about this creature, this plant factor.”

RELATED CONTENT: Qween Jean Made Historical past, Megan Thee Stallion Repped The Hotties And Queen Latifah Delivered A Full-Circle Second At The 2026 Tony Awards

Juggling Theater, Marvel, and Motherhood

To talk with James at this level of her profession is to witness an artist working on the absolute peak of her powers, seamlessly managing a rare, multi-disciplinary workload. In a show of stamina, she has spent current weeks concurrently performing as Audrey, filming a large tv sequence, and stepping backward via her personal historical past.

“I went again into The Ebook of Mormon for per week, and I used to be capable of revisit Nabulungi, this function that I received a Tony Award for, and I’m additionally enjoying Audrey,” she reveals. “I’m doing that on the similar time. After which I’m additionally in the course of taking pictures the third season of Daredevil, which is a tv present that I’m on. I’m doing all of these issues at the very same second. So, tonight I’m enjoying Audrey, yesterday I used to be on set taking pictures, and Sunday I used to be enjoying Nabulungi twice on Broadway. And I’m a mom to this unbelievable three-and-a-half-year-old child. I simply suppose all elements of my artistry are being stretched. All elements of my day are full of issues that I like doing.”

“I feel I’ve been round lengthy sufficient to acknowledge that these moments are uncommon, and to say that you just’re drained but in addition, in each second of look of exhaustion, I’m so grateful. This received’t final eternally, and never everybody will get to expertise this. So, that’s the factor that’s been completely different about this second. I feel with the hindsight of how exhausting I’ve labored and the way exhausting it’s, I’m capable of actually absorb all these moments for what they’re, which is lightning in a bottle, and never rush it. Not want it over. To not get up within the morning and say, ‘Oh, I can’t wait to go to mattress tonight,’ however to essentially fill all the moments that I’m wholesome and alive and residing on this unbelievable metropolis and making work—theater, tv, creating characters, telling tales, making connections with folks, followers.”

Pleasure as a Radical Observe

This philosophy of deep presence is closely strengthened by her life as a mom. “It’s so fleeting. My daughter’s three and a half… you really neglect how brief they’re infants for. It’s so exhausting. They don’t sleep, you don’t know them, you’re frightened each minute. But it surely’s such a brief time period, and to be wishing any of these moments away is like—there’s vanity in that, since you’re going to be at a degree once you’re going to overlook these moments. When my child remains to be asking me to rub her again for half-hour…in 5 years she is perhaps like, ‘Get out of my room.’ So, I attempt to simply have a humorousness about all of it.”

Finally, James’s present skilled and private outlook is rooted in a bit of knowledge handed down via her theater neighborhood—a lesson on selecting pleasure via the inevitable seasons of hardship. She remembers a dialog concerning a longtime colleague from her Ebook of Mormon days, John Eric Parker, who just lately endured the tragic lack of his husband to most cancers.

“We name John Eric the Oracle,” James shares softly. “One other good friend was speaking about John Eric and mentioned, ‘He’s so sensible,’ and I used to be attempting to determine why he’s so sensible. And that is what I got here up with: which is that all the exhausting issues in his life that he’s going via, you’ll be able to simply see that he focuses on nonetheless discovering pleasure, and nonetheless with the ability to chuckle, and utilizing all of those exhausting issues as classes to search out extra pleasure and never as a possibility to be down or to be detrimental or accountable or jealous. I would like that type of life. I need to have the great and the unhealthy additionally assist me discover pleasure in my life. That’s an actual lesson for this time in my life, too—this kind of stroke of luck I’ve had career-wise the previous few months.”

As Little Store of Horrors continues to attract packed homes, James hopes audiences go away with an appreciation for the vocal execution and socio-political layers wrapped up in camp. “I hope that they suppose that we sound fierce,” she smiles. “It is a singer’s singing present. There’s plenty of singing on this. I feel the present is a bit little bit of an allegory concerning the ills of want for fame and fortune. Seymour type of sells his soul to the satan a bit bit… it may be a slippery slope once you’re attempting to achieve the very best highs. However I hope folks simply have a very good time and chuckle.”

Past the laughs, the vocals, and the puppetry, James acknowledges that her very presence on that stage signifies a shift within the theater world. Black girls are not pressured to remain inside designated lanes, however are empowered to rewrite the classics solely on their very own phrases.

“We joke that it’s bizarre—it’s one way or the other turn out to be a Black present,” James concludes. “It’s a tremendous factor to see illustration and other people of colour in starring roles in New York Metropolis in these traditional musicals. It’s actually one thing particular, and to not be ignored or glossed over. It’s actually particular.”

Little Store of Horrors is at present working Off-Broadway on the Westside Theatre.

RELATED CONTENT: “Purple Rain” Is Being Turned Into A Musical For Broadway